See the New Mad Sociologist at http://madsociologistblog.wordpress.com

Getting Past the Gun Control Mythology!

If we are going to have a discussion about guns, let’s have one unhindered by the same old MYTHOLOGY

 

We need to have a discussion about guns. I don’t think this is a controversial statement. What may be controversial is the nature of that discussion. For many years now the discourse on guns in the United States has hinged on two assumptions. First, individuals have a right to bear arms, and infringing on that right makes citizens more vulnerable to criminal violence as well as to government tyranny. Second, it is in the public interest to regulate access to deadly weapons as the irresponsible and reckless use of such instruments poses a legitimate hazard to citizens. These are not unreasonable claims. The dominance of the “gun rights” paradigm, however, seems to have the upper hand over the “public interest” end of the debate.

Yet what do we really know about the reality of guns in America? There is the great cowboy mythology of the “peacemaker” side-arm carrying gun slinger enforcing justice and civilizing the west. This is juxtaposed with the reality that many towns in the west forbade firearms in order to control violence. There are the damning statistics on how violent the United States is, with homicide rates that make the rest of the industrialized world cringe. The fear that predators exist around every corner and only a well armed citizenry can protect itself from the psychopaths among us. We even have the extremist rhetoric that gun ownership is the only defense against the possibility of an American dictatorship.

Do these rhetorical elements stand up to reality? The answer is no. Because our existing paradigms on gun control do not adequately describe the realities of guns or violence in the United States we cannot have a legitimate debate on the issue. We need to look at the data, decide what is relevant, and then move on from there.

This shouldn’t be a tall order, but it is. When special interests steer the debate they tend to make available the data that they like, and downplay the data that they don’t. This strategy is not specific to either side of the discourse, but it doesn’t take much research to determine which “side” owns the debate at this juncture. Try it yourself. Type “crime and guns” into a Google Search. Most of what you will get is an explanation on why more guns equate to less crime. Of course, criminals in a heavily armed society are less likely to ply their trade lest they run the risk of getting shot. Among the most notable sources you will find is author John Lott, who wrote More Guns, Less Crime. This perspective is very popular among the many gun owners and gun rights activists in the United States. Is it true, however?

For that we have to access some more literature that addresses Lott’s hypothesis. And the research just does not support his claim. Such research is, however, hard to find. Part of the reason for that is the NRA. According to the New York Times, pressure from this very powerful organization often axes research that does not conform to the NRA’s position. Truth cannot become a part of the dialogue when the research is censored.

Despite this obstacle, however, there is research out there that sheds doubt on the ?”more guns less crime” hypothesis. Most notably is a research study done by Ian Ayers and John Donahue III published in the Stanford Law Review. They tested Lott’s position, but expanded the parameters to include more logistical data and state specific variables. They find that Lott’s conclusions did not hold water once the research parameters were extended, as it should have if the “more guns less crime” hypothesis was correct. There was no strong correlation between violent crime and shall-issue laws for carrying firearms. In fact, the only statistically significant outcome was, in fact, an increase in robberies associated with shall-issue laws. Since Ayers and Donahue could not develop a satisfactory model to explain this increase, however, the researchers caution that this result is most likely an artifact of unknown external variables. The Ayers/Donahue research is supported by a study done by the National Research Council. There is no reliable data to suggest a link between crime and gun possession.

I did my own evaluation of this research by comparing gun ownership to murder rates at the national level. I figured that national statistics may be revealing since nations are more likely to control the movement of weapons across borders than are states. For instance, such a comparison among states or municipalities that have strong controls regarding weapons possession may be skewed if there are municipalities with more permissive laws nearby. This is less likely with national boundaries. I used murder rates because there are variable cultural perspectives among nations with regard to that which constitutes a “violent” crime. Murder, however, is a fairly stable construct, especially if defined as intentional killings. My results are below.

It is visually obvious that the lines for Gun Ownership (in blue) and for Murder per Capita (in red) look nothing like each other. This would indicate that there is a low correlation between the two lines. But to be sure I ran the correlation between the two and found it to be -.22. In other words, there is a very weak correlation suggesting that as gun ownership increases murder rates decrease. But a .2 correlation is very weak and is most likely the result of other variables. An r² suggests that gun ownership explains, perhaps, 5% of the variance. So 95% of the murder rates cannot be explained using gun ownership as a model.

This data is illuminating, but also problematic for both ends of the gun debate. On one hand, gun ownership is not a reasonable defense against murder, or any other crime for that matter. On the other hand, access to guns does not appear to create a threat to the public. The bloodbaths as a result of looser gun laws as predicted by gun control advocates just do not happen. Yes, there is regional data used by both sides to support their positions, but this data is inconsistent and not predictive.

Why? Shouldn’t one side or the other be true? Not necessarily. It could be that ease in acquiring and carrying a gun does act as a deterrent, but makes it easier for criminals to acquire guns that counter that deterrent. We know that guns are used every day in defense. We also know that guns are used every day to commit crimes. It could be that the deterrent factor on one end does not compensate for, or minimally compensates for, the ease of criminal gun ownership on the other end, and vice versa.

The next part of the debate I wanted to test had to do with freedom. It is a core belief among gun rights advocates that gun ownership equates to preserving freedom from government tyranny. Sounds good, but is it true? Turns out, no. There is no correlation between freedom and gun ownership. To test this I used the data from Freedom House’s Freedom in the World 2010 report.

Again, the chart speaks for itself. The data is divided into Political Rights (in blue), Civil Rights (in red) and Gun Ownership (in orange). The correlation between civil rights and political rights is clear, but gun ownership does not follow anything close to the same trajectory. In fact, the correlation between political rights and gun ownership was -.19, explaining 4% of the variance. This indicates that as gun ownership increases political rights decrease, but with a very weak correlation indicating that there is no definable relationship. The correlation for civil rights was -.23 explaining 5% of the variance. Gun ownership is no guarantee of freedom. Nor is gun ownership a threat to freedom.

So if the fundamental assumptions on both sides of the gun debate are irrelevant, where does that leave us? I would say that this should advance the debate because we don’t have to be bogged down by the irrelevant. If we are freed from the fear of leaving our citizens vulnerable or subject to bloodletting, and we are freed from the fear of tyranny, we can move on to matters that are significant.

The fact remains that the United States has a very high violent crime rate including an obscene homicide rate. If guns do not explain this phenomenon then what does? A very revealing set of data offers a suggestion for areas we might want to consider. The chart at left was created by Richard Florida for The Atlantic. We don’t have to ban guns, but this graph implies some suggestions that might make a difference (of course, as Florida rightly states, correlation is not causation so the following suggestions are purely speculative). We must address poverty and the instability of the working class as these are positively correlated with gun violence. This is reinforced by the significance of economic output as a negative correlation for gun violence (as economic output increases, gun violence decreases). Standard of living and well-being also appear to have a meaningful correlation, as SofL and well-being increases, gun violence decreases. These variables never enter the debate about guns and gun violence.

Some simple reforms that may make a difference according to the graph are an assault weapon ban (if self defense and freedom are irrelevant, what do you need an AK-47 for?), trigger locks and safe storage requirements. These are reforms that do not infringe upon a right to bear arms. Remember, in the time of our founding fathers there were no assault weapons.

The larger issues, however, are also touched upon by the graph. McCain states were positively correlated with gun violence while Obama states were negatively correlated. This shouldn’t place blame at the foot of Senator McCain. However, it is safe to assume that McCain states tend to embrace conservatism more than Obama states (although this could be an artifact of many other variables outside of conservatism). Conservatism is predicated on the primacy of individualism as a central tenant. It might be a good idea to look into the influence of individualism on society in such a way that has not been done since Max Weber in The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. When people feel that they are on their own, that justice is in their own hands, could that be a contributing factor in violence? And, if so, how is that sense self-defined justice influenced by the presence of guns? Is it a coincidence that the United States is seen as the most individualistic society in the world, as well as being the most fatally violence industrialized culture? Again, this is speculation, but speculation that I believe is worth looking into.

 

 

 

 

393 Responses

  1. Pingback: garment business daily

  2. Pingback: facebook123

  3. Pingback: facebook123

  4. Pingback: Cheap Marble Tile Ireland

  5. Pingback: Boston Apartments

  6. Pingback: Queens locksmith

  7. Pingback: opportunities for investment

  8. Pingback: Brookline apartments

  9. Pingback: Montclair condos for sale

  10. Pingback: Location Bungalow Ile Maurice

  11. Pingback: Acne No More

  12. Pingback: Keurig Review

  13. Pingback: Bungalow Ile Maurice

  14. Pingback: Schwinn 240

  15. Pingback: jetsetter

  16. Pingback: Mauritius Accommodation

  17. Pingback: Villas in Mauritius

  18. Pingback: Credit Card Debt Relief London On

  19. Pingback: iphone 5

  20. Pingback: cute switzerland girl

  21. Pingback: best way to get rid of acne

  22. Pingback: how to get rid of acne fast

  23. Pingback: Location Bungalow Ile Maurice

  24. Pingback: Property Management Cambridge

  25. Pingback: Allston Apartments

  26. Pingback: mold inspection Miami

  27. Pingback: Jersey City locksmith

  28. Pingback: locksmith Brockton

  29. Pingback: locksmith Medford

  30. Pingback: Arlington locksmith

  31. Pingback: locksmith Lynn

  32. Pingback: Long Island locksmith

  33. Pingback: Belmont Locksmith

  34. Pingback: Lexington locksmith

  35. Pingback: Boston Locksmith

  36. Pingback: Baltimore locksmith

  37. Pingback: Portland locksmith

  38. Pingback: Tampa locksmith

  39. Pingback: Charlotte locksmith

  40. Pingback: Atlanta locksmith

  41. Pingback: acupuncture naples fl

  42. Pingback: San Diego locksmith

  43. Pingback: Los Angeles locksmith

  44. Pingback: Las Vegas Catering

  45. Pingback: vitamin b complex side effects

  46. Pingback: Minneapolis Moving Companies

  47. Pingback: Bronx locksmith

  48. Pingback: honda element accessories

  49. Pingback: Chicgo locksmith

  50. Pingback: Location Villa Ile Maurice

  51. Pingback: haas cabinets

  52. Pingback: Mauritius Villa Rental

  53. Pingback: partsunlimited

  54. Pingback: Best Acne Medication

  55. Pingback: Sexy Novels

  56. Pingback: Mauritius Apartments

  57. Pingback: thermal infrared

  58. Pingback: vis night

  59. Pingback: Location Vacances Ile Maurice

  60. Pingback: optics night

  61. Pingback: How To Cure Acne Fast

  62. Pingback: motion sensor camera

  63. Pingback: insomnia definition

  64. Pingback: quoizel chandelier

  65. Pingback: dating with herpes

  66. Pingback: Los Angeles locksmith

  67. Pingback: Acne Diet

  68. Pingback: Eric S Brown Parking

  69. Pingback: drinks with vodka

  70. Pingback: USA dating sites

  71. Pingback: mitsubishi tv parts

  72. Pingback: solar energy savings

  73. Pingback: Mesothelioma Lawyers San Diego

  74. Pingback: easy tether

  75. Pingback: click here

  76. Pingback: 800-511-2896

  77. Pingback: Sexless Marriage

  78. Pingback: 800-319-5243

  79. Pingback: ugg boots sale uk

  80. Pingback: hostgator coupon codes

  81. Pingback: Quick Weight Loss

  82. Pingback: kindle touch 3g

  83. Pingback: accelerated nursing programs

  84. Pingback: get free ipad

  85. Pingback: single mum in London

  86. Pingback: nook vs kindle

  87. Pingback: xxnx

  88. Pingback: Football

  89. Pingback: flashplayer

  90. Pingback: free sex videos

  91. Pingback: How To Change The Background Of A Picture Online

  92. Pingback: How To Promote A Product

  93. Pingback: Canadian Tire Canada

  94. Pingback: metal roofing prices

  95. Pingback: yoga teacher training toronto

  96. Pingback: wet pour safety surfacing

  97. Pingback: metal roofing prices

  98. Pingback: metal roofing prices

  99. Pingback: metal roofing prices

  100. Pingback: scotty mccreery and lauren alaina

  101. Pingback: prostate forte

  102. Pingback: how to remove a wart

  103. Pingback: diecast camaro

  104. Pingback: invicta watches for men

  105. Pingback: coupon

  106. Pingback: electronic cigarette

  107. Pingback: article

  108. Pingback: know more about seo

  109. Pingback: Brian Keith photographer

  110. Pingback: giant robot tunnel six

  111. Pingback: Free Glee Episodes

  112. Pingback: Online Marketing Blog

  113. Pingback: renewable energy insurance

  114. Pingback: real weddings

  115. Pingback: Online Sunglasses Shop

  116. Pingback: Business IT Support Boca Raton

  117. Pingback: dentists essendon

  118. Pingback: smokeless cigarette

  119. Pingback: north london removals

  120. Pingback: womens fitness

  121. Pingback: film streaming

  122. Pingback: dvd covers

  123. Pingback: kitten advice

  124. Pingback: internetmarketingtoolstips.org

  125. Pingback: Japan Figure

  126. Pingback: Social Media Marketing in Mesa Arizona

  127. Pingback: free work at home jobs

  128. Pingback: Secret Lead Factory

  129. Pingback: http://www.webkoranga.org

  130. Pingback: Subliminales

  131. Pingback: new balance men

  132. Pingback: what does short sale mean

  133. Pingback: Conspiracies

  134. Pingback: fiji vacations

  135. Pingback: gadget reviews

  136. Pingback: Black Friday Bowflex SelectTech 552

  137. Pingback: best black friday sale

  138. Pingback: estepona properties

  139. Pingback: real estate development process

  140. Pingback: Wedding photographers in Miami

  141. Pingback: Mark

  142. Pingback: restaurant marketing plan

  143. Pingback: kambing etawa

  144. Pingback: data recovery

  145. Pingback: Coin sale

  146. Pingback: job board software reviews

  147. Pingback: Rain Gutters

  148. Pingback: blackjack strategy

  149. Pingback: path too long utility

  150. Pingback: quick weight loss

  151. Pingback: Performance coaching

  152. Pingback: Geld verdienen im Internet

  153. Pingback: craftsman radial arm saw thermal overload

  154. Pingback: mykoreaimport

  155. Pingback: microsoft office 2010

  156. Pingback: Yuoporn

  157. Pingback: Yuvutu

  158. Pingback: best prenatal vitamins

  159. Pingback: security company

  160. Pingback: Twin Girls

  161. Pingback: workplace accidents

  162. Pingback: Ministry of Manpower

  163. Pingback: click here

  164. Pingback: John Timber

  165. Pingback: cloud computing companies

  166. Pingback: Cheap Dentafresh Dog Food

  167. Pingback: best bbq in Kansas City

  168. Pingback: Joel

  169. Pingback: used high performance boats for sale

  170. Pingback: Youtube to mp3

  171. Pingback: webcam sex

  172. Pingback: used cars lancaster pa

  173. Pingback: xbox 720

  174. Pingback: pet fix

  175. Pingback: essential oils wholesale

  176. Pingback: it support washington dc

  177. Pingback: webcam sex

  178. Pingback: PapiJump free

  179. Pingback: how to get your ex girlfriend back

  180. Pingback: AKO Webmail

  181. Pingback: webscribble coupon

  182. Pingback: VOLKSwagon golf parts

  183. Pingback: ciGAR humidors

  184. Pingback: 350Z FLOOr mats

  185. Pingback: Unleash Your Voice

  186. Pingback: Emergency Generator

  187. Pingback: metalica

  188. Pingback: Cheap Garden Furniture

  189. Pingback: Bowtrol Colon Control Review

  190. Pingback: hershey pa hotels

  191. Pingback: home improvement harrisburg pa

  192. Pingback: odt

  193. Pingback: kitchen remodeling lancaster

  194. Pingback: car insurance lancaster pa

  195. Pingback: mountain cabin

  196. Pingback: restaurants lancaster

  197. Pingback: website design

  198. Pingback: roofer new york

  199. Pingback: payments on credit cards

  200. Pingback: grants for single moms

  201. Pingback: free online auctions

  202. Pingback: Digest It

  203. Pingback: Car stereo installation san diego

  204. Pingback: electric garage heater

  205. Pingback: cat lovers

  206. Pingback: web design tutorials

  207. Pingback: equine insurance

  208. Pingback: creatina e whey

  209. Pingback: collecting on bad checks

  210. Pingback: new pinball machines

  211. Pingback: used car dealers harrisburg pa

  212. Pingback: va disability attorneys

  213. Pingback: it consultant new york city

  214. Pingback: wedding receptions lancaster

  215. Pingback: pennsylvania electric suppliers

  216. Pingback: paving reading

  217. Pingback: emprego online

  218. Pingback: maquinas nespresso

  219. Pingback: edIBle arrangements

  220. Pingback: infra cams

  221. Pingback: Notary Los Angeles

  222. Pingback: voiture sans permis occasion

  223. Pingback: Get laid for free

  224. Pingback: Carpal Tunnel Exercises

  225. Pingback: webcam sex

  226. Pingback: Crest 3D Toothpaste

  227. Pingback: Gothic

  228. Pingback: long term care insurance quotes

  229. Pingback: Hemroid Cures

  230. Pingback: plumbers in Houston

  231. Pingback: Sprout Link Building Service

  232. Pingback: post office jobs

  233. Pingback: Motorcycle Vests

  234. Pingback: Buy Facebook Likes

  235. Pingback: dress watches

  236. Pingback: womens sunglasses

  237. Pingback: Jenny Sanders

  238. Pingback: Scarlett Johansson Nude

  239. Pingback: Beta HCG Levels

  240. Pingback: know more about seo

  241. Pingback: retractable name badge holders

  242. Pingback: Bill Ferrows

  243. Pingback: Play

  244. Pingback: Forex VPS

  245. Pingback: hcg diet

  246. Pingback: e cig

  247. Pingback: roof truss

  248. Pingback: super colon cleanse

  249. Pingback: Digestive Health Products

  250. Pingback: Web Design Naples FL

  251. Pingback: trailers

  252. Pingback: singorama

  253. Pingback: carnage polanski trailer

  254. Pingback: Pasang Iklan Rumah

  255. Pingback: Car Manufacturers

  256. Pingback: indian restaurant

  257. Pingback: part time jobs in melbourne

  258. Pingback: Manny Pacquiao Vs Marquez 3

  259. Pingback: fundraising online

  260. Pingback: Glee Season 3 Episode 4

  261. Pingback: UB Classic 3-pack Retro Fashion Style Sunglass

  262. Pingback: movie reviews

  263. Pingback: TOP 1 Oli Sintetik Mobil-Motor

  264. Pingback: Local Contractors

  265. Pingback: geschenkideen

  266. Pingback: car stereo san diego

  267. Pingback: Windeltorten

  268. Pingback: Loodgieter harlingen

  269. Pingback: Medical Assistant Recognition

  270. Pingback: Web hosting reviews

  271. Pingback: itfc

  272. Pingback: buy facebook fans

  273. Pingback: camaro tshirt

  274. Pingback: Lethal Commissions bonus

  275. Pingback: Save Your Relationship

  276. Pingback: Geburtstagsgeschenke

  277. Pingback: Weihnachtsgeschenke

  278. Pingback: trilastin review

  279. Pingback: kredite aus der schweiz

  280. Pingback: cook chicken

  281. Pingback: Los Angeles Bail Bond

  282. Pingback: wine cooler reviews

  283. Pingback: hypoallergenic dog food

  284. Pingback: Hostgator

  285. Pingback: automatic pill dispensers

  286. Pingback: Forex Robot Review

  287. Pingback: web designer in san diego

  288. Pingback: tips to speed up my pc

  289. Pingback: treatment for bv at home

  290. Pingback: Poker Books

  291. Pingback: smsf townsville

  292. Pingback: Online Website Builder

  293. Pingback: cheap web hosting uk

  294. Pingback: Cheap Backlinks

  295. Pingback: Clipping Path Service

  296. Pingback: X Videos

  297. Pingback: Geburtstagsgeschenkideen

  298. Pingback: business administration

  299. Pingback: where can i get amazon gift card

  300. Pingback: where can i get amazon gift card

  301. Pingback: enhancexl pills

  302. Pingback: Cable Providers Alexandria Virginia

  303. Pingback: Fashion Rings

  304. Pingback: drink driving solicitors

  305. Pingback: colon cleanse tablets

  306. Pingback: ps3 jailbreak 3.72

  307. Pingback: Web Design Nottingham

  308. Pingback: online dating sites

  309. Pingback: Executive

  310. Pingback: Kindle Fire

  311. Pingback: Top

  312. Pingback: hyip

  313. Pingback: great lakes loan

  314. Pingback: Plus Size Clearance

  315. Pingback: pool supply stores

  316. Pingback: yoga for beginners

  317. Pingback: melatonin for dogs

  318. Pingback: energy and the environment

  319. Pingback: cage fighting uk

  320. Pingback: Michigan furniture stores

  321. Pingback: Free Mp3 Downloads

  322. Pingback: window cleaners sw11

  323. Pingback: asics shoes nimbus

  324. Pingback: theater tickets

  325. Pingback: mp5 airsoft

  326. Pingback: best small suv

  327. Pingback: Cheap Plus Size Halloween Costumes

  328. Pingback: Green Smoke electronic cigarettes

  329. Pingback: how to hack facebook password

  330. Pingback: Nicolas Cage

  331. Pingback: High Quality Articles

  332. Pingback: Easiest language to learn

  333. Pingback: getting ripped fast

  334. Pingback: Hair extensions training

  335. Pingback: jeffrey campbell wedges

  336. Pingback: laptops

  337. Pingback: free ipod

  338. Pingback: Adobe CS5 serials

  339. Pingback: independent financial advisor

  340. Pingback: men designer shoe

  341. Pingback: Irrigation Drip Systems

  342. Pingback: Online

  343. Pingback: free legal music downloads

  344. Pingback: glens travel site

  345. Pingback: persuasive text

  346. Pingback: the tool shop

  347. Pingback: amazon black friday sales

  348. Pingback: Cheap Airport Hotels

  349. Pingback: golf training aid

  350. Pingback: free iphone5

  351. Pingback: Hair Salon Marketing

  352. Pingback: pain management

  353. Pingback: MLM

  354. Pingback: spy cameras

  355. Pingback: locksmith in Berwyn IL

  356. Pingback: unlock iphone 5

  357. Pingback: Cigarette is enemy

  358. Pingback: tinnitus treatments

  359. Pingback: austin air conditioner repair

  360. Pingback: how to host minecraft server

  361. Pingback: hair protein at beauty supply

  362. Pingback: obagi reviews

  363. Pingback: hcg drops

  364. Pingback: discounted

  365. Pingback: classic r&b music

  366. Pingback: ecommerce design

  367. Pingback: bathroom furniture

  368. Pingback: The Best Information On Home Schooling

  369. Pingback: Hostgator Black Friday

  370. Pingback: night soviet

  371. Pingback: HDMI cable

  372. Pingback: wooden bar stools

  373. Pingback: stop smoking

  374. Pingback: Street Fighter 2

  375. Pingback: insomnia definition

  376. Pingback: Personal Financial Planner

  377. Pingback: Fibromyalgia

  378. Pingback: family guy full episodes

  379. Pingback: Wood Stove Fabius New York

  380. Pingback: backyard playsets

  381. Pingback: shopping reviews

  382. Pingback: nissan juke release date

  383. Pingback: rats are good pets

  384. Pingback: Xbox 360

  385. Pingback: penny stocks

  386. Pingback: wedding flowers

  387. Pingback: interior doors

  388. Pingback: Accu Tab

  389. Pingback: On Proving the Null Hypothesis in the Gun Debate | madsociologistblog

  390. Pingback: Everything You Know About the Gun Control Debate is Wrong | madsociologistblog

  391. Superb blog! Do you have any helpful hints for aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you suggest starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m totally confused .. Any suiesgtgons? Many thanks!

    15. May 2017 at 16:44

  392. happy mother’s day, you proud mamas!! your comments just goes to show how awesome you all are to have produced such awesome kids. they’re riding on home!!

    31. May 2017 at 14:15

  393. I’m grateful you made the post. It’s cleared the air for me.

    7. June 2017 at 05:46

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>