See the New Mad Sociologist at http://madsociologistblog.wordpress.com

Turning Against Capital Punishment

Death Penalty

It’s always difficult arguing against the death penalty.  It really doesn’t matter on what grounds one is making such an unpopular (in the US) stand.  The bottom line always devolves to the accepted eye for an eye concept that those who take a life deserve to die.  Indeed, when one considers the kinds of psychotic and sadistic killings that make the headlines, the rape/murders of children, mass murder, serial murder, it’s hard, if not impossible, to suggest that those who commit such violence do not deserve to die.  In fact, such people do deserve to die. I have no sympathy for such monsters, myself.

The question for me has always been, “can the state, or any institution for that matter, be trusted with the responsibility to decide who should live and who should die?” The sociology behind this question is clear.  No system known to man is flawless enough, rational enough, objective enough to make such a decision.

The United States is the only western power that uses the death penalty.  Since the death penalty was reinstated in the late seventies violent crime has risen and fallen without regard to capital punishment.  The system itself has been soundly criticized for being burdened with racial, ethnic and class biases. The expense of pursuing capital punishment is astronomical, leading some to call for less time on death row with quicker implementation of the sentence.  Such a strategy would be disastrous considering the number of people who have been exonerated after many years on death row. The death of Cameron Todd Willingham in 2004 is just the only example of an innocent man being put to death. It’s unknown how many more innocent people have been executed as investigations almost always end after the death penalty has been successfully applied.

Willingham Family

This last fall The American Law Institute, the group that was instrumental in the reinstatement of the death penalty as a legitimate punishment, rescinded it’s opinion on capital punishment (this paragraph references the linked article).   The ALI cited “…the current intractable institutional and structural obstacles to ensuring a minimally adequate system for administering capital punishment.” According to the New York Times: “A study commissioned by the institute said that decades of experience had proved that the system could not reconcile the twin goals of individualized decisions about who should be executed and systemic fairness. It added that capital punishment was plagued by racial disparities; was enormously expensive even as many defense lawyers were underpaid and some were incompetent; risked executing innocent people; and was undermined by the politics that come with judicial elections.”

This is not news to sociologists.  Capital punishment decisions have a long history of reflecting societal prejudices rather than justice.  What is the acceptable level of error in a system designed to kill only those who are deserving?

504 Responses

  1. Pingback: garment business daily

  2. Pingback: Toko Online

  3. Pingback: bacterial vaginosis

  4. Pingback: bird feeders

  5. Pingback: bulk email submitter

  6. Pingback: iwaashooked

  7. Pingback: modern beach chairs

  8. Pingback: Swimwear

  9. Pingback: no cost classified ads

  10. Pingback: flat mate finders

  11. Pingback: click this

  12. Pingback: room buddies

  13. Pingback: free people search

  14. Pingback: top 10 online casinos

  15. Pingback: dallas dwi attorney

  16. Pingback: thevitaminsandherbs

  17. Pingback: thebulkherbs

  18. Pingback: mountainroseherbs

  19. Pingback: trusted doctor network

  20. Pingback: cheap seo services

  21. Pingback: guide

  22. Pingback: hollywood

  23. Pingback: super stars

  24. Pingback: La Liga

  25. Pingback: SEO Strategy

  26. Pingback: temcos.com

  27. Pingback: Detoxing From Alcohol

  28. Pingback: free ipad 2

  29. Pingback: outdoor movies Sydney

  30. Pingback: automotive advertising agency

  31. Pingback: solar queensland

  32. Pingback: Acuspeed 24 Diet

  33. Pingback: facebook123

  34. Pingback: burial urns

  35. Pingback: nj website design

  36. Pingback: Sugar Daddy

  37. Pingback: Floor sanding and polishing

  38. Pingback: zumbido

  39. Pingback: Sacramento Plumbing service man

  40. Pingback: Personal trainer Sacramento

  41. Pingback: Cheapest Porcelain Tile Northern Ireland

  42. Pingback: chiropractor elk grove

  43. Pingback: apartments Brookline

  44. Pingback: Mauritius Self Catering Holidays

  45. Pingback: Acne No More

  46. Pingback: Keurig Review

  47. Pingback: Schwinn 240

  48. Pingback: miami fashion week

  49. Pingback: Mauritius Villas

  50. Pingback: Mauritius Accommodation

  51. Pingback: portrait painting

  52. Pingback: yoga spain

  53. Pingback: pilula do dia seguinte

  54. Pingback: yolk chicago

  55. Pingback: thomas hack

  56. Pingback: Location Vacances Ile Maurice

  57. Pingback: internet marketing consultant

  58. Pingback: rent marbella

  59. Pingback: Debt Relief Help Ontario

  60. Pingback: send money to Indonesia

  61. Pingback: send money to Vietnam

  62. Pingback: halloween costumes 2011

  63. Pingback: substance abuse treatment

  64. Pingback: iphone 5

  65. Pingback: how to make extra money online now

  66. Pingback: low fat diet

  67. Pingback: best way to get rid of acne

  68. Pingback: switzerland dating agencies

  69. Pingback: how to get rid of acne fast

  70. Pingback: Bungalow Ile Maurice

  71. Pingback: Quincy Property Management

  72. Pingback: mold inspection Miami

  73. Pingback: locksmith in Anaheim

  74. Pingback: locksmith

  75. Pingback: Cambridge locksmith

  76. Pingback: Mission Hill Apartments

  77. Pingback: Arlington locksmith

  78. Pingback: Somerville locksmith

  79. Pingback: Seattle locksmith

  80. Pingback: Tucson locksmith

  81. Pingback: Oakland locksmith

  82. Pingback: Atlanta locksmith

  83. Pingback: chicago strippers

  84. Pingback: San Diego locksmith

  85. Pingback: Portland catering

  86. Pingback: Omaha Moving Companies

  87. Pingback: Manhattan locksmith

  88. Pingback: Brooklyn locksmith

  89. Pingback: vitamin b6 benefits

  90. Pingback: Queens locksmith

  91. Pingback: Location Villa Maurice

  92. Pingback: bathroom window treatments

  93. Pingback: oreilly parts

  94. Pingback: Best Acne Medication

  95. Pingback: Villas Mauritius

  96. Pingback: Erotic Books

  97. Pingback: List Builder Pro

  98. Pingback: Mauritius Apartments

  99. Pingback: newyork dresses

  100. Pingback: ipod adapter for car stereo

  101. Pingback: thermal image hunting

  102. Pingback: Mauritius Accommodation

  103. Pingback: image tube

  104. Pingback: How To Cure Cystic Acne

  105. Pingback: define depression

  106. Pingback: bega lighting

  107. Pingback: Brooklyn locksmith

  108. Pingback: Eric S Brown Parking

  109. Pingback: Acne Diet

  110. Pingback: how to lay ceramic tile

  111. Pingback: dating sites

  112. Pingback: herpes dating sites

  113. Pingback: No Sex Marriage

  114. Pingback: easytether download

  115. Pingback: Mesothelioma Lawyer San Diego

  116. Pingback: SEO

  117. Pingback: Merchant Services Protection Plan

  118. Pingback: Merchants Discount Health Plan

  119. Pingback: portable appliance testing

  120. Pingback: hostgator coupon codes

  121. Pingback: kindle 3g touch

  122. Pingback: Quick Weight Loss

  123. Pingback: fast track nursing programs

  124. Pingback: test and keep ipad

  125. Pingback: nook vs kindle review

  126. Pingback: click here

  127. Pingback: flash player

  128. Pingback: click this

  129. Pingback: what is depression caused by

  130. Pingback: agooodexperience

  131. Pingback: free sex videos

  132. Pingback: Canadian Tire Canada

  133. Pingback: free website traffic

  134. Pingback: yoga teacher training toronto

  135. Pingback: Unique Sterling Silver Jewelry

  136. Pingback: wet pour

  137. Pingback: prostate forte review

  138. Pingback: removing a wart

  139. Pingback: coupon

  140. Pingback: electronic cigarettes

  141. Pingback: blog

  142. Pingback: Claripro

  143. Pingback: andrews jewelers

  144. Pingback: domaca muzika

  145. Pingback: know more about seo

  146. Pingback: giant robot tunnel six

  147. Pingback: Internet Marketing Blog

  148. Pingback: wedding photography

  149. Pingback: insomnia dallas

  150. Pingback: iphone

  151. Pingback: osterizer blender replacement parts

  152. Pingback: essendon dental

  153. Pingback: e cigarette tips

  154. Pingback: blogger reference

  155. Pingback: Business Computer Support

  156. Pingback: diet pills

  157. Pingback: film streaming

  158. Pingback: dvd covers

  159. Pingback: make money online

  160. Pingback: http://www.uhtyinuqha.com

  161. Pingback: weaning cats

  162. Pingback: Free Internet Marketing Software

  163. Pingback: Japan Figure

  164. Pingback: Subliminales

  165. Pingback: my website

  166. Pingback: Electric Mopeds

  167. Pingback: hardship letter for short sale

  168. Pingback: Cults

  169. Pingback: new balance men

  170. Pingback: holidays to fiji

  171. Pingback: Black Friday Nikon COOLPIX L120

  172. Pingback: earn money from home

  173. Pingback: Cheap TVs Black Friday Sale

  174. Pingback: Voyeur Webcam

  175. Pingback: estepona apartments

  176. Pingback: http://nebuladevice.cubik.org/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=50906

  177. Pingback: Wedding photographers Miami

  178. Pingback: custom snapback hats

  179. Pingback: cancer fundraising

  180. Pingback: how much water to drink

  181. Pingback: Bank Recruitment

  182. Pingback: restaurant business plan

  183. Pingback: sexless marriage

  184. Pingback: teeth whitening kits

  185. Pingback: Look at this

  186. Pingback: how to change the background of a picture online

  187. Pingback: replica watches

  188. Pingback: Cardiff To Bristol Airport

  189. Pingback: Cardiff To Bristol Airport

  190. Pingback: susu etawa

  191. Pingback: 3ds homebrew

  192. Pingback: Real Estate

  193. Pingback: data raid recovery

  194. Pingback: job board software script

  195. Pingback: The Truth About Six Pack Abs

  196. Pingback: Investing in Real Estate

  197. Pingback: path too long utility

  198. Pingback: quick weight loss

  199. Pingback: blackjack card counting

  200. Pingback: Geld verdienen im Internet

  201. Pingback: sell your house fast

  202. Pingback: best Hypnotist

  203. Pingback: mykoreaimport

  204. Pingback: mlm prospecting systems

  205. Pingback: server for business

  206. Pingback: Yuoporn

  207. Pingback: Twin Girls

  208. Pingback: excel training

  209. Pingback: security company

  210. Pingback: Work Pass

  211. Pingback: road traffic accident investigation

  212. Pingback: garmin forerunner

  213. Pingback: Tim Allen

  214. Pingback: robert de niro

  215. Pingback: watch the video here

  216. Pingback: Small Business SEO

  217. Pingback: camera pen

  218. Pingback: Learn how to get more twitter followers

  219. Pingback: cloud computing companies

  220. Pingback: Recycling of Paper

  221. Pingback: Cheap Puppy Dog Food

  222. Pingback: Cheap car insurance St. Joseph

  223. Pingback: Travis

  224. Pingback: Christian

  225. Pingback: hypoallergenic dog food

  226. Pingback: diet pills

  227. Pingback: Lagos

  228. Pingback: used boats for sale

  229. Pingback: lower left back pain

  230. Pingback: buy youtube views

  231. Pingback: comedy carpet

  232. Pingback: Youtube to mp3

  233. Pingback: webcam sex

  234. Pingback: lancaster dodge

  235. Pingback: pavillion

  236. Pingback: webcam sex

  237. Pingback: home builder nashville

  238. Pingback: Which HDMI Cable should I buy

  239. Pingback: aromatherapy

  240. Pingback: gourmet coffee

  241. Pingback: computer repair alexandria va

  242. Pingback: stair spindles

  243. Pingback: mail box rental pasadena

  244. Pingback: striping

  245. Pingback: PapiJump online free

  246. Pingback: ms exchange 2010

  247. Pingback: exchange 2010

  248. Pingback: car paint protection

  249. Pingback: reverse cell phone lookup free with name

  250. Pingback: rustoleum countertop transformations

  251. Pingback: webscribble coupon

  252. Pingback: Empowerment Coach

  253. Pingback: 350Z Floor Mats

  254. Pingback: Veterinary Sterilizers

  255. Pingback: metalica

  256. Pingback: Cheap Garden Furniture

  257. Pingback: chiropractor denver colorado

  258. Pingback: public speaking skills

  259. Pingback: cloud computing model

  260. Pingback: wooden gazebos

  261. Pingback: amish country lancaster pa

  262. Pingback: siding lancaster pa

  263. Pingback: odt

  264. Pingback: computer networking denver

  265. Pingback: tourist attractions pennsylvania

  266. Pingback: restaurant lancaster pa

  267. Pingback: john deere parts

  268. Pingback: sleigh beds

  269. Pingback: homes for sale in lititz pa

  270. Pingback: lexus lfa

  271. Pingback: cloud computing companies

  272. Pingback: exercise cardiovascular

  273. Pingback: oil mist collector

  274. Pingback: copper weathervane

  275. Pingback: concrete contractors pennsylvania

  276. Pingback: cargo trailers

  277. Pingback: supply chain consulting

  278. Pingback: leadership development training

  279. Pingback: pc repair fort lauderdale

  280. Pingback: roofing companies new york

  281. Pingback: pc repair miami

  282. Pingback: dissolve blood clots naturally

  283. Pingback: credit card payments

  284. Pingback: grants for single mothers

  285. Pingback: free online auctions

  286. Pingback: Digest It Review

  287. Pingback: medical billing and scheduling software

  288. Pingback: key west charter flights

  289. Pingback: Car stereo installation san diego

  290. Pingback: garage heater

  291. Pingback: air purifier reviews

  292. Pingback: web design dvd

  293. Pingback: dog lovers

  294. Pingback: ironing ormskirk

  295. Pingback: creatina e whey

  296. Pingback: hertorarstock

  297. Pingback: Gynexin Reviews

  298. Pingback: Wedding Venues South Wales

  299. Pingback: oranum psychic

  300. Pingback: mobiele website

  301. Pingback: collection articles for debt recovery

  302. Pingback: ford hats

  303. Pingback: cupolas

  304. Pingback: blister packaging

  305. Pingback: department of defense contractor

  306. Pingback: hospital lancaster

  307. Pingback: solar power maryland

  308. Pingback: arcade basketball games

  309. Pingback: wedding lancaster pa

  310. Pingback: jeep york pa

  311. Pingback: lawn care lancaster pa

  312. Pingback: electricity suppliers in pa

  313. Pingback: computer consultant nyc

  314. Pingback: temple university housing

  315. Pingback: free cloud storage

  316. Pingback: lancaster video productions

  317. Pingback: computer repair new haven ct

  318. Pingback: Junk Yards MN

  319. Pingback: Fort Lauderdale plumber

  320. Pingback: Immobilien Ahlen

  321. Pingback: free stuff

  322. Pingback: Foundation Financial Group

  323. Pingback: Glee Season 3 Episode 6

  324. Pingback: Adult Halloween Costumes

  325. Pingback: Medical Sterilization

  326. Pingback: Garden Yard Composters

  327. Pingback: emergency power

  328. Pingback: SEO en francais

  329. Pingback: multilingual seo

  330. Pingback: SEO Deutschland

  331. Pingback: Real Estate

  332. Pingback: Giveaways

  333. Pingback: bulk email marketing

  334. Pingback: aleve and alcohol

  335. Pingback: Driver Training California

  336. Pingback: dores de estomago

  337. Pingback: Tree Service New Egypt nj

  338. Pingback: blog

  339. Pingback: edIBLE ARrangements

  340. Pingback: IBS treatment

  341. Pingback: travelpillowbest

  342. Pingback: night google

  343. Pingback: cookingwithherbs

  344. Pingback: theherbsspices

  345. Pingback: sexvideos

  346. Pingback: location voiture sans permis

  347. Pingback: Backlink Battleplan

  348. Pingback: webcam sex

  349. Pingback: Crest Professional

  350. Pingback: Gothic Shopping

  351. Pingback: used car loan

  352. Pingback: Houston plumbers

  353. Pingback: watkins products

  354. Pingback: bose speakers for sale

  355. Pingback: watches for man

  356. Pingback: laugh videos

  357. Pingback: Jenny Sanders

  358. Pingback: Moving Company Tucson

  359. Pingback: Russian dating

  360. Pingback: thegardenherbs

  361. Pingback: Naples Web Design

  362. Pingback: Beta HCG Levels

  363. Pingback: cheap hair transplant

  364. Pingback: SEO Money Software

  365. Pingback: read more about seo

  366. Pingback: is it legal to download youtube videos

  367. Pingback: Forexhandel

  368. Pingback: colon cleansing products

  369. Pingback: Truss

  370. Pingback: e cigarettes

  371. Pingback: conversational spanish phrases

  372. Pingback: Digestive Disorders

  373. Pingback: Memory

  374. Pingback: release

  375. Pingback: polanski carnage

  376. Pingback: indian restaurant near bristol

  377. Pingback: Spira Men's Odyssey Cushioned Running Shoe

  378. Pingback: sport news

  379. Pingback: Local Contractors

  380. Pingback: TOP 1 Oli Sintetik Indonesia

  381. Pingback: geschenkideen

  382. Pingback: Windeltorten

  383. Pingback: Loodgieter Leeuwarden

  384. Pingback: car stereo san diego

  385. Pingback: Medical Assistant Recognition

  386. Pingback: unlock new iphones

  387. Pingback: Lethal Commissions

  388. Pingback: itfc forum

  389. Pingback: wholesale flowers

  390. Pingback: best way to get back at your ex

  391. Pingback: megavideo

  392. Pingback: Los Angeles Bail Bonds

  393. Pingback: online marketing san diego

  394. Pingback: Hostgator

  395. Pingback: Cheap Notebook Discount

  396. Pingback: natural remedies for bacterial vaginosis

  397. Pingback: web hosting cheap

  398. Pingback: Cheap Backlinks

  399. Pingback: ipad

  400. Pingback: gas furnace price

  401. Pingback: vocal software

  402. Pingback: Fashion Rings

  403. Pingback: Web Services Nottingham

  404. Pingback: free dating

  405. Pingback: Kindle

  406. Pingback: hyip

  407. Pingback: emergency vehicle lights

  408. Pingback: Plus Size Clearance

  409. Pingback: Upscale

  410. Pingback: direct loans consolidation

  411. Pingback: how to become anything

  412. Pingback: yoga for beginners

  413. Pingback: mma self defense

  414. Pingback: grow long hair

  415. Pingback: tennis shoes reebok

  416. Pingback: airsoft minigun

  417. Pingback: lauri hink

  418. Pingback: Weddings Buxted Park

  419. Pingback: volkswagen credit

  420. Pingback: cheap hotels

  421. Pingback: Wine Reviews

  422. Pingback: how to hack a facebook account

  423. Pingback: Janet Wilson

  424. Pingback: High Quality Articles

  425. Pingback: Increase vertical leap

  426. Pingback: Knowledge Base

  427. Pingback: Quality Plumbing Service

  428. Pingback: spanish grammar online

  429. Pingback: bilingual advantages

  430. Pingback: get ripped fast

  431. Pingback: Hair extension training

  432. Pingback: Company Website Design

  433. Pingback: computers

  434. Pingback: free apple

  435. Pingback: Drip Irrigation System

  436. Pingback: chicago men shoe

  437. Pingback: glens travel site

  438. Pingback: roofers lancaster

  439. Pingback: free downloading music

  440. Pingback: page ranks checker

  441. Pingback: groom wedding speech

  442. Pingback: Airport Lounges

  443. Pingback: golf swing tips

  444. Pingback: pain management

  445. Pingback: women's lingerie

  446. Pingback: spy camera

  447. Pingback: locksmith in Berwyn IL

  448. Pingback: freeappleipad2

  449. Pingback: Cigarette Pills

  450. Pingback: how to cure tinnitus

  451. Pingback: austin ac repair

  452. Pingback: attorneys in lancaster pa

  453. Pingback: protein balance

  454. Pingback: Tarot Gitano

  455. Pingback: adult social network

  456. Pingback: landscaping

  457. Pingback: popularity

  458. Pingback: 500 calorie diet

  459. Pingback: love

  460. Pingback: My Technology Website

  461. Pingback: Oklahoma Workers Compensation Defense

  462. Pingback: bathroom

  463. Pingback: furniture stores

  464. Pingback: Best Year: The Year I Homeschooled My Child!

  465. Pingback: best electric shavers

  466. Pingback: night thermal

  467. Pingback: Home Office Furniture

  468. Pingback: cams infra

  469. Pingback: Vacation All Inclusive

  470. Pingback: diet program

  471. Pingback: Apple Battery

  472. Pingback: Sales Video Formula Now

  473. Pingback: stop smoking aid

  474. Pingback: Hostgator Black Friday

  475. Pingback: Jogos Online

  476. Pingback: Montclair Storage

  477. Pingback: antique gold jewelry

  478. Pingback: insomnia definition

  479. Pingback: mirro pressure cooker

  480. Pingback: Outdoor bar stools

  481. Pingback: Heating Oil Prices Tully

  482. Pingback: Los Angeles Chiropractor

  483. Pingback: family guy full episodes

  484. Pingback: Accu Tab

  485. Pingback: Wood Pellet Stove Skaneateles

  486. Pingback: kids swing sets

  487. Pingback: Stella McCartney

  488. Pingback: Views

  489. Pingback: Marketing company san diego

  490. Pingback: financial planner Brisbane

  491. Pingback: Financial Advisers

  492. Pingback: Divorce in Pennsylvania

  493. Pingback: office 2007

  494. Pingback: making money online

  495. Pingback: anket doldur para kazan

  496. Pingback: wedding flower arrangements

  497. Pingback: site brasileiro de philadelphia

  498. Pingback: san rafael doors

  499. Pingback: Palawan Hotel

  500. Pingback: lafayette louisiana accident lawyer

  501. Pingback: lafayette church

  502. Pingback: black friday jewelry

  503. Pingback: black friday 2011 printer

  504. Pingback: black friday software

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>